Karlgaard Towers, located on the upper campus of the University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire (UWEC) in Eau Claire, Wisconsin, consists of two ten-story residence halls: Towers North and Towers South. Originally constructed in 1966, the buildings contain a combined 630 residence rooms.
Both towers underwent renovations between 2017 and 2019. Towers South reopened to students in fall 2018, while renovations to Towers North continued through 2018–2019.
Following the reopening of Towers South, students and university personnel reported winter-season building performance issues, including surface condensation, water staining, and suspected mold growth on interior wall surfaces. Similar moisture-related problems were also identified in Towers North during its renovation.
These conditions raised concerns about building enclosure performance and moisture management, requiring technical evaluation to identify the underlying issues and determine appropriate solutions.
Services Provided
Who We Serve
Jim was able to zero in on the problem quickly and was timely in his effort. He explained the issues well and communicated the solution options and associated cost in a manner useful to us. His cost estimates proved to be thorough and accurate providing us the confidence we need in our decisions."
Andrew Nord – Facilities Planning & Construction – Construction Project Manager
Gallery
Challenges
We would definitely work with Jim and CR-BPS again. They were timely, thorough and created good value for the dollar we spent."
Andrew Nord – Facilities Planning & Construction – Construction Project Manager
Approach
University Facilities staff installed data loggers to monitor temperature and relative humidity conditions in affected dormitory rooms. CR-BPS conducted a comprehensive building diagnostics investigation to identify the root causes of moisture accumulation on interior exterior-wall surfaces.
The investigation included:
- Review of existing building and project documentation.
- Interviews with University Facilities staff.
- Analysis of winter data logger records, including relative humidity, air temperature, and dew point conditions within the affected rooms.
- Building airtightness testing.
- Infrared thermographic scanning to identify air leakage and potential thermal deficiencies.
- The data logger results confirmed excessive indoor relative humidity at specific times across multiple days during the winter season.
The diagnostic analysis identified several contributing factors, including the Basis of Design’s reliance on operable windows to provide ventilation air, uncontrolled air leakage between rooms and floors, and resulting condensation within the exterior wall assemblies.
CR-BPS evaluated two primary approaches to controlling condensation on interior wall surfaces and within building assemblies:
- Improve surface temperatures: Increase the temperature of building assembly surfaces to reduce the potential for condensation.
- Control moisture exposure: Manage indoor relative humidity and the movement of moist air toward cold building surfaces and within wall assemblies.
The existing exterior wall assemblies at Towers Hall made the addition of interior insulation impractical. As a result, controlling winter indoor humidity was identified as the more feasible approach.
CR-BPS evaluated practical ventilation strategies that could address the moisture conditions while considering construction costs, building constraints, and long-term operational needs.
Jim did a great job sharing and explaining information with our A/E consultant who we would ultimately ask to implement the solutions. CR-BPS communicated the findings and solutions well with everyone. Jim and the A/E worked well together."
Andrew Nord – Facilities Planning & Construction – Construction Project Manager
Results
CR-BPS’s building diagnostics identified excessive indoor relative humidity, poorly insulated building enclosures, thermal bridging, inadequate mechanical ventilation in dormitory rooms and uncontrolled air leakage as contributing factors to winter condensation and potential mold growth.
Rather than recommending extensive modifications to the exterior wall assemblies to improve thermal and airtightness control, CR-BPS identified indoor humidity management and improved ventilation as a more practical direction.
The initial recommendation focused on compartmentalizing individual dormitory rooms and installing dedicated energy recovery ventilators (ERVs) through the exterior walls. An alternative was a centralized, whole-building ventilation system.
Following review of CR-BPS’s report and additional consultation with maintenance and University engineering staff, UWEC determined that a whole-building ventilation system, although more expensive, would provide the best long-term solution.
In 2020, Greenfire Management Services LLC was awarded the construction contract for the Karlgaard Towers Condensation Repairs project, covering both North and South Towers.
The renovation included the installation of four new 7,400-CFM energy recovery units and supporting ventilation distribution systems serving the dormitory rooms in both towers.
The new ductwork extended vertically from the rooftops through the building to each floor, with horizontal branch lines distributing ventilation air to individual dormitory rooms.
Construction was completed in multiple phases during the summer months to minimize disruption to university operations and student housing.
Through detailed building diagnostics and practical recommendations, CR-BPS helped UWEC understand the causes of the moisture-related problems and evaluate long-term ventilation solutions for its residence halls.
The solutions recommended by CR-BPS are working great and we would for sure consider working with them again. We would consider using CR-BPS on our project teams such as “owner’s representative” during design, construction and commissioning. We are always looking for other architects and building science consultants."
Andrew Nord – Facilities Planning & Construction – Construction Project Manager